28-01-2022 Black Sea bulk exports at risk if Russia-Ukraine tensions escalate, By Nidaa Bakhsh, Lloyd’s List
Coal, grains, and steel may be the largest commodity groups to be affected by intensifying Russia-Ukraine tensions. According to Ocean Analytics, in 2021 about 231 MMT of dry bulk commodities were shipped from ports around the Black Sea, of which 85% emanated from Ukraine and Russia. While 9 MMT was destined for other ports in the Black Sea, 96% passed through the Bosphorus Strait to more distant shores such as China, its founder Ulf Bergman said, adding that the Black Sea could become inaccessible, either entirely or partially, for commercial shipping should conflict arise.
While handysizes and supramaxes dominated trades historically, panamaxes and capesizes have increased their market share, almost doubling to 30% since 2015, his analysis shows. Volumes shipped on panamaxes grew to 67 MMT, while capesizes carried 39 MMT from the region last year. Mr Bergman said that if conflict were to choke off gas supplies to Europe in the event of sanctions on Russia, more thermal coal could find its way to Europe from further afield, thereby increasing tonne-miles. Sources could include Australia and South Africa.
According to brokerage Braemar ACM, it may be difficult to replace all the Russian supplies due to supply constraints elsewhere, namely Colombia and the US. In addition, the Indonesian ban on coal exports, although lifted, has put pressure on seaborne supply. While Russian coal accounted for 42.5% of European coal imports, these volumes only represented 19.3% of Russian coal exports, with the majority moving to places such as China, dry bulk analyst Mark Nugent said in a note.
Trades from Canada could however add to bulk carrier demand. Meanwhile, grains disruptions would have more of a negative near-term impact. Ukrainian corn is expected to have a bumper season, with record production of 42 MMT in the 2021/22 marketing year, a gain of almost 39%. Exports usually take place in the fourth quarter of the year following into the first quarter. However, Ukrainian-grown corn only accounted for 14.8% of seaborne trade last year, at 19.3 MMT, due to weather-related disruptions, according to Braemar, which affected yields.
The possibility of sanctions on Russian grains, namely wheat, is unlikely to have a significant impact on trade flows of this crop, it said, as major buyers include China, Iran, and Turkey. If the US and the European Union sanctions are realized, the minor wheat volumes that do head west will likely force buyers to look to North American wheat, which has faced drought during this crop year, keeping supply in this region tight, Mr Nugent said. “Although there may be short-term disruptions to grain shipments, there is still time for tensions to subside before the seasonal peak in Black Sea grain liftings in August, when the majority of the region’s wheat crop is exported,” he said. “The unsettling possibility of a war in the Ukraine, which seems unlikely, would have a more broad-based negative impact on the dry market longer term, with ports in the Black Sea likely to halt operations,” he concluded.
A spokeswoman at international grains giant Cargill said its export terminal at Yuzhny, in which it has a 51% stake, was still operating normally, but it was monitoring the situation closely for any developments.